In the event that you had a billion bucks and desired to do something about environment modification, what would you do? for a number of men and women, that's not a rhetorical concern. an instagram post early in the day this month from amazon creator jeff bezos announcing he had scattered $791m across different weather charities may be the latest in a trend that features bill gates and michael bloomberg. and theres more on the way in which bezoss contributions are simply the beginning of his $10bn bezos earth fund.

However the interesting thing about this workout is that, also for the most privileged thoughts on earth, it's not obvious how to overcome the duty. can it be more straightforward to purchase technologies which could just take years to mature or even to spend money on clean energy in establishing countries, that may reduce air pollution straight away? or perhaps political spending is one of efficient approach, to push policy in a climate-friendly path? or can you simply start building water walls to get ready for unavoidable?

Each billionaire takes their tack. gates went down the technology path, supporting projects that range from atomic fusion to molten-salt batteries. he has got also spent their amount of time in writing and discussing the subject, and contains a book on climate modification coming-out next year. bloomberg features focused on the governmental part, including investing over $170m on a campaign to close coal-fired energy plants; its success is part associated with explanation united states carbon emissions have actually fallen recently.

Bezos is the most recent arrival to the club along with his approach has also been the blandest. he slashed five cheques of $100m to five regarding the biggest, most established green teams in america and distributed lower amounts to a couple others, including $30m for study into saving carbon in plant origins.

Its a good motion, but it feels as though exactly that the kind of cheque-writing exercise that middle-class us americans typically save when it comes to end of the year to increase income tax deductions. for bezos, chief executive of amazon, routinely celebrated as one of the most disruptive innovators on earth, their environment donations tend to be distinctly without either disturbance or development.

Recent occasions at amazon make bezoss giving look quite defensive. in september 2019, staff members started staging walkouts to protest the companys climate policies, creating a significant picture issue. a few of the workers demands have been met amazon followed a target of net-zero carbon emissions by 2040.

It is also purchasing tens of thousands of electric cars and guarantees that half its shipping operations would be carbon-free by the end of this ten years. together with business has actually bought naming rights to a seattle sports stadium and labeled as it in the event you missed the point the climate pledge arena.

But not one of the rather masks that amazon was a lot slowly to do something on climate than other tech rivals such as for example bing and microsoft. its carbon emissions remain vast: in 2019, amazon emitted 51 million tonnes of carbon-dioxide equivalent (including its workplaces, warehouses and delivery cars). thats over the country of sweden.

Matthew nisbet, a professor at northeastern university in boston who studies this area, states bezos has become the greatest single source of weather offering on earth creating a huge weather modification halo. but that halo isn't constantly merited, he claims: these types of big gift suggestions could pose a conflict of great interest for environmental charities, which can usually be more important of amazons environmental record. (the recipients of bezoss grants all deny this, saying obtained rigid guidelines to avoid any dispute of great interest.)

Whether or not bezos isn't trying to purchase off his critics or placate their staff members, there's one obvious shortcoming in his strategy: he's got tossed money in the issue, but hasnt apparently matched by using method. nor has actually he talked or written much towards concern about perhaps not in comparison to various other environment billionaires.

Contrast their recent 160-word instagram post with all the numerous of words published by gates. likewise, bloomberg is very dedicated to their weather work and that can be viewed trudging round the un climate conferences yearly, offering somewhat jet-lagged speeches.

Without a doubt, looking right back at bezoss speeches and interviews lately, you will find tips that amazon bosss real passion is actually for something different totally moving away from this earth entirely. a lifelong room obsessive, he invests about $1bn a year inside the area business, blue origin, and contains explained it as the most essential work im doing.

His sight is that humans will one day inhabit room, residing in huge orbiting colonies. we will need to leave this earth, he has got stated, pointing to the growing populace. his idea is the fact that heavy industry will even transfer to room, making some light manufacturing behind on earth and any people who would like to stay. but bezos himself hopes is on that rocket ship. despite the grand ambitions associated with the bezos world fund, can you actually trust the planet to a person who has already been thinking about making it behind?

Leslie hook could be the fts environment and clean energy correspondent. ; gillian tett returns next week

Follow on twitter to find out about our newest stories initially. tune in to our podcast, society call, in which ft editors and special guests discuss life and art into the time of coronavirus. subscribe on apple, spotify, or anywhere you listen.