Spanish construction rebuilds after market collapse

Property developer Olivier Crambade founded Therus Invest in Madrid in 2004 to build offices and retail space. For five years business went quite well, and Therus developed and sold more than €300m of properties. Then Spain’s economy imploded, taking property with it, and Mr Crambade spent six years tending to Dhamma Energy, a solar energy […]

Continue Reading


Euro suffers worst month against the pound since financial crisis

Political risks are still all the rage in the currency markets. The euro has suffered its worst slump against the pound since 2009 in November, as investors hone in on a series of looming battles between eurosceptic populists and establishment parties at the ballot box. The single currency has shed 4.5 per cent against sterling […]

Continue Reading


RBS falls 2% after failing BoE stress test

Royal Bank of Scotland shares have slipped 2 per cent in early trading this morning, after the state-controlled lender emerged as the biggest loser in the Bank of England’s latest round of annual stress tests. The lender has now given regulators a plan to bulk up its capital levels by cutting costs and selling assets, […]

Continue Reading


China capital curbs reflect buyer’s remorse over market reforms

Last year the reformist head of China’s central bank convinced his Communist party bosses to give market forces a bigger say in setting the renminbi’s daily “reference rate” against the US dollar. In return, Zhou Xiaochuan assured his more conservative party colleagues that the redback would finally secure coveted recognition as an official reserve currency […]

Continue Reading


Carney: UK is ‘investment banker for Europe’

The governor of the Bank of England has repeated his calls for a “smooth and orderly” UK exit from the EU, saying that a transition out of the bloc will happen, it was just a case of “when and how”. Responding to the BoE’s latest bank stress tests, where lenders overall emerged with more resilient […]

Continue Reading

Categorized | Banks, Financial

ENRC faced 11th-hour hitch over listing

Posted on April 30, 2013

The controversial London flotation of Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation in 2007 faced an 11th hour hurdle after lawyers and auditors found evidence that financial records at the Kazakhstan-based miner had been falsified or destroyed, according to people familiar with the matter.

At least one director of the FTSE 100 company was so concerned about the revelations that they considered whether the 2007 initial public offering should be put on hold, one person familiar with the matter said. Another person involved with ENRC at the time added: “There was a question over whether we should go ahead.”

    The Kazakh miner is now the subject of a criminal investigation by the Serious Fraud Office, primarily over whistleblowing allegations made since then amid criticism of the standards of London listing rules.

    A few weeks before its December 7 2007 float, ENRC received a report commissioned from Herbert Smith into a network of sales intermediaries in Russia. This set out evidence the law firm said was uncovered by PwC, ENRC’s auditors, of the falsification of audit data in Russia and the destruction of records relating to cash payments to the three Central Asian oligarchs who still have big stakes in ENRC.

    An adviser involved with ENRC at the time of the listing said the problems with Russian trading were considered by UK Listing Authority while vetting the oligarchs – Alexander Mashkevich, Patokh Chodiev and Alijan Ibragimov – as directors of the company. He said this had been seen as a last-minute hitch to the deal.

    “They [the UKLA] saw a lot of red flags,” he said. The other person familiar with the float said: “[Directors] were told by PwC and the banks that there might be a problem.”

    The Herbert Smith report, part of which has been seen by the FT, stated that Russian sales intermediaries sold $870m of minerals in 2004-2006. It said sales agents collected part of each payment in cash to pass on to the three oligarchs who still have big stakes in ENRC. An employee who collected this money first told Herbert Smith investigators that he had destroyed related records, and later that he had kept none.

    On the issue of audit data, the law firm stated that confirmations of sales figures sent to PwC, supposedly from 32 different businesses, all arrived on the same day, bearing addresses written in the same handwriting and having all been posted at roughly the same time in Moscow.

    According to the report, PwC contacted two purchasers of ENRC commodities that had purportedly sent audit confirmations for 2006. Neither knew anything about it, Herbert Smith concluded.

    Moreover, large volumes of data were wiped from computers in the Moscow office of ENRC, states the report, dated September 25 2007. According to one named witness, a manager “asked employees to leave their computers switched on . . . so that information could be deleted due to the impending IPO”.

    This week, ENRC said the Russian sales network was “thoroughly investigated prior to the IPO, the investigation was closed and all allegations of wrongdoing were dismissed”.

    Deutsche Bank, which advised the company on the float, Herbert Smith, PwC and the UK Listings Authority all declined to comment.

    Herbert Smith found no evidence that ENRC or its management knew about the false audit confirmations or to suggest that, excepting one named employee, “reliance [could] not be placed upon the representations for audit purposes of current management”.

    The flotation went ahead after PwC signed off financial data in the prospectus as “true and fair”. The “historic” Russian sales system is described in detail on page 16, among other “risk factors”. The falsification of audit confirmations is disclosed separately in a single paragraph on page 217 in “Part XIII: Additional Information”, which also states “much” of the deleted data were recovered.